SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY)

Secondary decision view: valuation · portfolio context · the data you need before acting on a single-source signal.
Neutral

SPY is rated NEUTRAL as its expensive valuation is offset by an elevated implied volatility reading, while the absence of a reliable floor prevents a clear directional bias.

  • The current P/E of $31.81 sits at the 93.3rd percentile, earning a 'expensive' verdict via web-search percentile data.
  • Implied volatility of 21.9% ranks at the 97th percentile over the past year, flagged as 'high' — typically associated with elevated market uncertainty.
  • No valid valuation floor could be established (0 valid floors), and the suitability verdict is 'unsuitable', meaning there is no clear safety net to anchor downside expectations.
Verdict bucket from deterministic rule (validation / floor distance / risk alerts). LLM narration only — never picks the bucket.

BUY-ZONE DECISION rule signal

Sign in to set your floor price for SPY and unlock the buy-zone decision summary.
Sign in

Macro context

Across past macro events, SPY 5d reaction has been net positive +0.4%
13 event categories · 107 samples · 55 up / 36 down · macro-beta evidence only
Per-category detail · macro beta breakdown
fed-fomc-rate-cycle → avg 5d +0.7% 12 samples · 5 up / 6 down
taiwan-strait-tension → avg 5d +0.8% 12 samples · 6 up / 3 down
oil-shock → avg 5d +0.2% 10 samples · 5 up / 2 down
us-china-tariff-escalation → avg 5d +0.3% 10 samples · 5 up / 3 down
big-ipo-event → avg 5d +0.3% 9 samples · 5 up / 3 down
bank-crisis → avg 5d +0.9% 8 samples · 5 up / 2 down
big-tech-earnings-shock → avg 5d +1.2% 7 samples · 4 up / 2 down
election-uncertainty → avg 5d +0.1% 7 samples · 3 up / 3 down
natural-disaster → avg 5d +0.3% 7 samples · 4 up / 2 down
pandemic-emergency → avg 5d -0.0% 7 samples · 5 up / 2 down
sovereign-debt-crisis → avg 5d +0.3% 7 samples · 4 up / 3 down
china-property-crisis → avg 5d +0.7% 6 samples · 3 up / 2 down
russia-ukraine-war → avg 5d -1.8% 5 samples · 1 up / 3 down
Macro-beta evidence: how this ticker historically reacted to broad macro shocks. Not a thesis-level call — for that, you have to read the news and decide.

RULES & ALERTS FIRING

Sign in to see which rules are firing on SPY in your portfolio.
Sign in

VALUATION

Expensive No cross-validation data available
Trailing P/E
31.8
5-yr percentile: 93%
Based on S&P 500 ten-year monthly PE history percentile calculation; higher values indicate more expensive current valuation

Floor Engine

AI Valuation Recommendation ✓ OK
Floor
USD 567.36
Golden
USD 665.70
How we derived this
Floor USD 567.36历史峰值(ATH) × (1 − 50%) 回撤。原因:场景方法选举出的底价远低于当前价(< 40%),引擎判断这些方法的历史样本已被过时的定价区间主导(典型 re-rated 股票),回退到一个对 wheel/options 仓位更可执行的回撤型底价。

Golden USD 665.70ATH × (1 − 35%)(同一回撤方法,更浅档位)。

注:下方场景卡片显示的 DIVIDEND/VALUATION/EPV 数字是引擎仍计算了但未采纳的原始候选 — 保留可见以便审视引擎判断。
AI Synthesis
SPY 当前市盈率处于历史第 93 分位,估值偏高,市场已充分计入未来增长,面临盈利不及预期或估值压缩的风险。在此背景下,通过历史峰值(ATH)回撤模型进行推算。以历史峰值 $756.48 为基准,我们计算出潜在下行底价为 $567.36(该价格对应 ATH 的 75% 回撤)。若市场出现回调,黄金买点价格在 $665.7(对应 ATH 的 88% 回撤)。鉴于该模型是启发式回撤分析,当前推算置信度为低。
Updated 2026-06-08
Glossary (click to expand)
Forward P/E
P/E using analysts' next-12-month EPS estimates. More forward-looking than trailing P/E, but exposed to forecast error.
Trailing P/E
P/E using actual EPS from the last 12 months. Distorted by one-time events (asset sales, impairments) until they roll out of the window.
P/B (Price-to-Book)
Stock price / book value per share. Meaningful for asset-driven sectors (banks, insurers); high values are normal for asset-light sectors (tech, consumer).
PEG
P/E ÷ earnings growth rate — \"how much P/E you pay per 1% of growth\". <1 = cheap-ish, >2 = priced-in.
Regime-mismatch drawdown model
When P/E distribution undergoes a structural shift (business transformation, sector re-rating), traditional \"revert to historical P/E percentile\" misleads. This model uses historical max drawdown × current EPS instead.
EPV (Earnings Power Value)
Greenwald framework: assume zero growth + current earning power is sustainable. Yields a conservative lower bound (asset + franchise value).
Heuristic Fallback
Backup estimator used when the primary method (P/E percentile, yield reversion, etc.) is unreliable due to data issues. **Lower confidence** — reference only, not auto-execute.
Confidence
Primary method applicable → high; multiple methods agree → medium; single heuristic fallback → low. Low confidence means review before acting.
Floor data pending
The next daily scan will fill in hard-logic floors for SPY. If it doesn't appear after a few days, contact the admin.

YOUR WATCHLIST CONTEXT

○ anonymous
What you'll see after sign-in
Your floor
$XXX.XX
Your golden
$XXX.XX
Market
XXX

· Your personal floor / golden price overlay on the live price

· Per-ticker rule alerts when this stock crosses your thresholds

· Position P&L overlay — what this ticker means inside your full portfolio

Sign in to unlock →

IMPLIED VOLATILITY

CURRENT IV 21.9% HV (30D) 12.2% IV RANK (1Y) 97 HIGH
IV vs HV · last 1 year

Earnings Reactions

No earnings reaction data found for SPY in the last 2 years. Ticker may be invalid, lack public earnings history, or be too newly listed.

Is SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) overvalued right now?

SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) is currently trading at a trailing P/E of 31.8, sitting at the 93th percentile of its 5-year valuation history. A high percentile suggests the market is pricing the stock above its own historical norm — useful context before sizing a new position or selling premium against it.

SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) — what's the SELL PUT risk profile?

Selling cash-secured puts on SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) is a common income strategy, but the right strike depends on your floor price (the level you'd happily own at) and the option chain's buffer/APY tradeoff. The full ladder view (deferred to a future release) ranks candidates by buffer percentage first, then APY — see the option ladder methodology for why buffer matters more than yield in this strategy.

SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) — which option strategy fits your view?

If you're bullish long-term but cautious near-term on SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY), SELL PUT into your floor zone collects premium while waiting for a better entry. If you already own it and are neutral-to-mildly-bullish, COVERED CALL caps upside but harvests time decay. The wrong strategy on the right ticker still loses money — match the trade to your view, not the other way around.

SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) — is now a good entry?

Entry timing on SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) is a function of your floor price (hard buy zone) and golden price (back-the-truck-up zone). Both are personal — set them in your watchlist and we'll alert you when the market hits either level.

FAQ

Why does SPY show different P/E numbers on different sites?

Different data providers use different earnings windows (TTM vs forward, GAAP vs adjusted) and update at different cadences. We surface trailing P/E with a 5-year percentile rank to give context — a P/E of 30 is hot for one stock and cold for another.

Does this page show SPY's implied volatility?

Not on this v0 page — the dedicated volatility tool covers IV with multi-source voting (IBKR + Polygon + yfinance). For pure IV lookup, use /tools/volatility. This page is for decision-stage queries that pull together valuation + portfolio context.

How is this different from Yahoo Finance or 雪球's SPY page?

Those sites are great for raw data discovery — last price, news, headline P/E. This page is built for the second look: you've already seen a single-dimension signal somewhere else, now you need multi-dimensional decision context (your floor, the valuation percentile, your portfolio overlay) in one view, not five tabs.